Skip to main
Nagle's Bagels
  • DiscountsCurrent Category
  • Most ordered
  • Sandwiches
  • Bagels
  • Bagels by the Dozen
  • Cream Cheese Tubs
  • Sides & Extras
  • Northfork Potato Chips
  • Pastries
  • Drinks
  • Merch

Nagle's Bagels Menu

378 Tompkins Ave, Brooklyn, NY

378 Tompkins Ave, Brooklyn, NY

·

Discounts

  • DiscountsCurrent Category
  • Most ordered
  • Sandwiches
  • Bagels
  • Bagels by the Dozen
  • Cream Cheese Tubs
  • Sides & Extras
  • Northfork Potato Chips
  • Pastries
  • Drinks
  • Merch

Most ordered

  • New Yorker.

    New Yorker

    $10.00+

  • Bagel.

    Bagel

    $2.50+

  • Nagle's Sunrise.

    Nagle's Sunrise

    $9.50+

  • Classic Nagle.

    Classic Nagle

    $16.00+

  • Veggie Nagle.

    Veggie Nagle

    $11.00+

  • Egg & Cheese Plus.

    Egg & Cheese Plus

    $8.25+

  • The B. A. T..

    The B. A. T.

    $11.75+

  • The Blue Velvet.

    The Blue Velvet

    $11.50+


Sandwiches

New Yorker

Fresh griddled eggs, applewood smoked bacon and white cheddar on a bagel, with your choice of sweet chili jam, chipotle mayo or ketchup.

$10.00+

New Yorker.

Nagle's Sunrise

Fresh griddled eggs, sausage patty and white cheddar on a bagel, with your choice of sweet chili jam, chipotle mayo or ketchup.

$9.50+

Nagle's Sunrise.

The B. A. T.

Our version of a BLT. Bacon, Avocado, Tomato -- plus Arugula & Chipotle Mayo

$11.75+

The B. A. T..

Classic Nagle

Sliced smoked salmon with plain cream cheese, capers, tomato and red onion on a bagel.

$16.00+

Classic Nagle.

Gotham

Sliced Smoked Salmon, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Garlic & Herb Cream Cheese, Tomato, Arugula & Sweet Chili Jam

$16.50+

Gotham.

The Red Hook

Our Latest! (and greatest?) Smoked Salmon, Bacon, Avocado, Arugula, Peppadew peppers, Chipotle Mayo

$15.25+

The Red Hook.

The Blue Velvet

Your choice of blueberry or scallion cream cheese with applewood smoked bacon, goat cheese, sweet chili jam, tomato & arugula.

$11.50+

The Blue Velvet.

Veggie Nagle

Fresh Scrambled Eggs, Goat Cheese, Avocado, Arugula & Sweet Chili Jam

$11.00+

Veggie Nagle.

Roadhouse

Jalapeño Cream Cheese, Smoked Ham, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Peppadew Peppers, Avocado & Arugula

$15.00+

Roadhouse.

Brooklyner

Fresh Griddled Eggs, Sliced Smoked Salmon, Scallion Cream Cheese, Goat Cheese & Arugula

$16.50+

Brooklyner.

East Side

Sliced Smoked Salmon, Garlic & Herb Cream Cheese, Avocado & Cucumber

$16.50+

East Side.

The Governor

Fresh Gourmet Tuna Salad, Arugula, Tomato, Onion & Applewood Smoked Bacon

$11.50+

The Governor.

The Nellie

Chunky Style All White Meat Chicken Salad, Peppadew Peppers, Tomato, Onions, & Arugula

$10.50+

The Nellie.

Nagle's Special

Fresh Griddled Eggs, Smoked Ham, Tomato, Onions & Sweet Chili Jam

$10.50+

Nagle's Special.

Spicy Nagle

Crumbled Goat Cheese, Peppadew Peppers, Avocado, Nagle's Chili Jam

$8.50+

Spicy Nagle.

Egg & Cheese Plus

Fresh griddled eggs and white cheddar on a bagel, with your choice of sweet chili jam, chipotle mayo or ketchup.

$8.25+

Egg & Cheese Plus.

Jerusalem

Fresh Hummus, Tomato, Red Onions, Cucumber & Arugula

$8.00+

Jerusalem.

Flatbush

A sweet-or-savory bagel sandwich: keep it sweet and salty with cream cheese, bacon and your choice of jelly, or make it savory with scallion cream cheese and chili jam.

$8.25+

Flatbush.

Whitefish Sandwich

ACME Whitefish Salad, Garlic & Herb Cream Cheese, Tomato & Arugula

$13.50+

Whitefish Sandwich.

Bagels

Build your own with your choice of spread.

Bagel

$2.50+

Bagel.

Bagels by the Dozen

Half Dozen Bagels

Please provide bagel choices in the special instruction box below. (Special instructions might not be available at all of our delivery partners, but are available at our website: naglesofbrooklyn.com)

$14.00

Half Dozen Bagels.

Dozen Bagels

Please provide bagel choices in the special instruction box below. (Special instructions might not be available at all of our delivery partners, but are available at our website: naglesofbrooklyn.com)

$27.00

Dozen Bagels.

Cream Cheese Tubs

8oz Plain Cream Cheese

8 oz tub of classic plain cream cheese.

$7.00

4oz Plain Cream Cheese

4 oz tub of classic plain cream cheese.

$2.75

4oz Plain Cream Cheese.

8oz Lox

$8.00

4oz Lox

$4.75

4oz Lox.

8oz Scallion

8 oz tub of scallion cream cheese.

$7.00

4oz Scallion

4 oz tub of scallion cream cheese.

$3.75

4oz Scallion.

8oz Veggie

$7.00

4oz Veggie

$3.75

4oz Veggie.

8oz Garlic & Herb

8 oz tub of garlic & herb cream cheese.

$7.00

4oz Garlic & Herb

4 oz tub of garlic & herb cream cheese.

$3.75

4oz Garlic & Herb.

8oz Jalapeño

8 oz tub of jalapeño cream cheese.

$7.00

4oz Jalapeño

4 oz tub of jalapeño cream cheese.

$3.75

4oz Jalapeño.

8oz Blueberry

8 oz tub of blueberry cream cheese.

$7.00

4oz Blueberry

4 oz tub of blueberry cream cheese.

$3.75

4oz Blueberry.

8oz Strawberry

8 oz tub of strawberry cream cheese.

$7.00

4oz Strawberry

4 oz tub of strawberry cream cheese.

$3.75

4oz Strawberry.

8oz Tofu

$7.00

4oz Tofu

$3.75

4oz Tofu.

Sides & Extras

Sliced Salmon (8 oz)

$15.50

Sliced Salmon (8 oz).

8oz. Whitefish Salad

ACME

$8.50

8oz. Whitefish Salad.

Tuna Salad (8 oz)

$7.50

Tuna Salad (8 oz).

4oz. Whitefish Salad

ACME

$4.25

4oz. Whitefish Salad.

Northfork Potato Chips

Salt & Vinegar Chips

$3.15

Salt & Vinegar Chips.

Barbecue Chips

$3.15

Barbecue Chips.

Salted Chips

$3.15

Salted Chips.

Sour Cream & Onion Chips

$3.15

Sour Cream & Onion Chips.

Pastries

Chocolate Chip Cookie

$4.00

Chocolate Chip Cookie.

Cinnamon Babka

$3.75

Cinnamon Babka.

Drinks

Iced Coffee (20 oz)

$5.50

Iced Coffee (20 oz).

Hot Coffee (16 oz)

$4.25

Hot Coffee (16 oz).

Hot Coffee (12 oz)

$3.25

Hot Coffee (12 oz).

Natalie's

16oz.

$4.99

Natalie's.

Boylan Soda

12oz Bottles 100% Pure Cane Sugar Soda

$3.50+

Boylan Soda.

Red Jacket

12oz.

$4.50

Red Jacket.

Ciao Bella Coconut Water

All-natural coconut water, non-GMO, one simple ingredient, and lightly refreshing.

$3.95

Ciao Bella Coconut Water.

Spindrift

12oz. Cans

$2.99

Spindrift.

Bottled Water

16.9oz

$1.65

Bottled Water.

Pellegrino

12oz. Bottles

$3.25

Pellegrino.

Loop Mission Cold-Pressed Juice

Cold-pressed juice made from rescued fresh fruits and vegetables. Choose your flavor.

$6.50

Loop Mission Cold-Pressed Juice.

Merch

Hat -- Think Pink

$24.00

Hat -- Think Pink.

Hat -- Black on Black

$24.00

Hat -- Black on Black.

Hat -- Snow White Camo

$22.00

Hat -- Snow White Camo.
brooklyn
  • Menu

  • Catering

  • Our Story

  • Press & accolades

  • We're Hiring

  • Gift Cards

Terms of serviceAccessibility

LUPACO LLC 2026 All Rights Reserved

Powered by Owner